The Finger Lakes region isnโt just a haven for tranquility; it’s also the birthplace of the ice cream sundae and home to the world’s largest pancake griddle!
So as you plan your next getaway to taste the sweet life, why not stay in one of the luxurious Finger Lakes cottage rentals where comfort meets history?

1. Charming Cottage on Seneca Lake
Escape to the serene shores of Seneca Lake with a stay at this bright, window-filled Finger Lakes cottage rental.
Perfectly placed to capture the stunning lakeside views, choose a cottageย that boasts a charming covered front porch built over the water. Unwind by the shale beach, grill your dinner outdoors, or gather around the fire pit. And with amenities like a paddleboat and kayak, plus a cozy interior that sleeps six, this cottage definitely epitomizes lakeside living at its finest!
2. Cozy New England Style Cottage on the Wine and Beer Trail
Nestled in the Town of Benton, this New England-style cottage marries rustic charm with modern amenities.
Ideal for those who appreciate the finer things, it sits right on the celebrated wine and beer trail, offering easy access to the best local sips. The covered outdoor grill area and fire pit also ensure your evenings are filled with warmth and good company, making it a quintessential pick for a nature retreat.

3. Lakeside Cottage in Keuka Park
Now if youโre a couple or a small family looking for some absolute privacy, then this quaint cottage on Keuka Park promises you an awesome stay!
With proximity to Keuka Lake State Park and nestled on a private road, find a cottage or place to stay that works for you surely provides stunning views and a peaceful retreat. Perfect for a smaller pack, itโs an absolute gem within the Finger Lakes cottage rentals, where you can enjoy sunsets by the lake or explore the nearby wine trail.ย
4. Lakefront Cottage in Honeoye
Experience tranquility at this newly remodeled cottage on Honeoye Lake, where every detail is crafted for comfort.
With a flat lot that meets 55 feet of beautiful lakefront, you can certainly enjoy easy access to the water and a dock for your boat. The cottage’s new grill and outdoor furniture, of course, make it a truly ideal spot for some lakeview dining, which is why many consider it as a premier choice among the many Finger Lakes cottage rentals in the area.

5. Quaint Country-Style Cottage in Geneva
Tucked away on Edgewood Beach, this country-style cottage offers a picturesque setting on the east side of Seneca Lake.
And with a rich array of amenities and close proximity to Genevaโs vibrant culture, itโs definitely an idyllic escape for those seeking a blend of relaxation and exploration. And if you ask us, it truly stands out among other Finger Lakes cottage rentals for its inviting atmosphere and accessibility to local wineries.
Discover the Best Finger Lakes Cottage Rentals
Ready to immerse yourself in the tranquil beauty of the Finger Lakes?
Without a doubt, each of these featured cottage rentals can offer you a unique gateway to the regionโs serene landscapes and rich history. Just imagine embracing uninterrupted relaxation amidst picturesque views. Now if those arenโt reasons enough to book a stay in one of these highly-rated Finger Lakes cottage rentals in your next getaway, then we donโt know what will.
Start planning your serene lakeside retreat with VacationCottage.com today!