Find the best cottages in Fire Island - We found 17 exact matches
About Fire Island Cottage Rentals on Vacation Cottage
For travelers seeking a comfortable and luxurious retreat in Fire Island, Vacation Cottage has you covered. Opt for a cottage rental, lake house retreat, or summer home resort and enjoy the flexibility of a hotel. With over 17 options available in Fire Island on Vacation Cottage, we can assist you in finding the perfect accommodation.
Elevate your next vacation with a picturesque cottage rental in Fire Island, offering top-notch amenities such as swimming pools, fitness centers, Wi-Fi, luxury suites, and fully-equipped kitchens. Discover unbeatable deals on outdoor vacation cottages, lake houses, and summer home retreats. Start planning your trip to Fire Island today and secure your accommodation in minutes on our website.
Whether it's a short-term getaway or a long-term seasonal stay, find the perfect cottage rental, lake house, or summer home for your favorite travel destinations. Compare options with Vacation Cottage and stay close to nature.
Frequently Asked Questions About Fire Island Rental Cottages
What are the top rated Cottage Rentals in Fire Island?
There are a lot of options in Fire Island. If you plan on staying in the Fire Island area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the top Cottage Rentals in Fire Island:
- Beach Cottage on Fire Island
- Classic Fire Island! Adorable Seaview Cottage - 2nd house from the beach.
- 5 houses from the beach, and 5 minutes from town - Ocean Beach 3-BR hideaway
- Chill Beachfront Cottage Amazing Bay & Sunset Views! Large Private Outdoor space
- Designer cottage with amazing view, serene deck & outdoor shower - walk to beach
- Idyllic Cozy Cottage in Davis Park, Fire Island - Weekly Rentals Now Available!
- Fair Harbor Fire island
- Newly Renovated Beauty! 2 bed plus Loft-Cottage Steps From Beach in Ocean Beach
- Coastal Cove Cottage
- Private 3BR 3BA Fire Island Cottage w/pool 4 min to harborl
How much does it cost to rent a cottage in Fire Island?
The average cost for a cottage rental in Fire Island is $766 per night. Vacation Cottage has a wide list of great cottages near Fire Island that would suit your needs. There are single and multiple rooms for solo trips or family vacations.
Are there any cottages in Fire Island that allow pets?
Yes, here are the top cottage rentals in Fire Island that allow you to bring your pet:
- Beach Cottage on Fire Island
- Coastal Cove Cottage
- Classic Fire Island! Adorable Seaview Cottage - 2nd house from the beach.
- 5 houses from the beach, and 5 minutes from town - Ocean Beach 3-BR hideaway
See all pet-friendly vacation rentals in Fire Island on Vacation Cottage
Do you have any rental cottages in Fire Island that are suitable for families?
Most of our listed cottages are suitable for families. Check out the complete list of cottages in Fire Island to find one that works for you.
Are there quality cottages in Fire Island that have indoor swimming pools?
As of 2025, the data from Vacation Cottage shows that there are Over 17 private swimming pools or cottages with indoor pools in the Fire Island area along with other great amenities.
Do any cottages in Fire Island have hot tubs?
About 17 cottages in Fire Island boast of premium hot tubs. Some of the popular places to stay with hot tubs include:
See all holiday vacation rentals in Fire Island on Vacation CottageAre there luxury cottages in Fire Island?
Yes, there are luxury cottages in Fire Island. Find more luxury, lakefront, winter, & last-minute cottage rentals near Fire Island.
